Monthly Commission Close Checklist for Insurance Agencies, Brokers, and MGAs

A step-by-step monthly commission close checklist for insurance agencies: collect statements, reconcile, resolve exceptions, pay producers, and report.
Checklist clipboard with every item checked beside a calendar and filed folders, representing a monthly commission close
Monthly Commission Close Checklist for Insurance Agencies, Brokers, and MGAs

Never miss new content

Subscribe to keep up with the latest news from AccountAim.

Checklist clipboard with every item checked beside a calendar and filed folders, representing a monthly commission close
Updated November 2026 · 6-minute read

Short answer

A monthly commission close for an insurance agency has five stages: collect every carrier statement, extract and validate the data, reconcile it against your AMS, resolve exceptions with carriers, then calculate producer pay and report revenue. Closing on reconciled data, not raw statements, keeps payouts accurate and revenue reporting trustworthy.

Stage 1: Collect statements

  • Pull statements from every carrier portal, inbox, and mailbox for the period.
  • Track which carriers have published and which are still outstanding.
  • Note carriers that changed formats so extraction can be checked.

Stage 2: Extract and validate

  • Extract line items into one structure: policy, insured, line, premium, rate, commission, transaction type.
  • Confirm extracted subtotals match each statement’s own totals.
  • Send unreadable or uncertain items to a reviewer.

Stage 3: Reconcile against your AMS

  • Match each statement line to its policy and transaction.
  • Compare paid commission with expected commission from carrier schedules.
  • List policies that should have paid but didn’t appear.
  • Flag underpayments, sliding-scale errors, true-up gaps, and chargebacks.

Stage 4: Resolve exceptions

  • Work one exception queue, grouped by carrier.
  • Send carriers documented claims with policy, expected, paid, and difference.
  • Carry unresolved items forward with a status and owner.

Stage 5: Pay producers and report

  • Calculate producer, CSR, and override pay from reconciled commission.
  • Apply chargebacks and true-ups according to plan rules.
  • Publish producer statements and answer questions from one source of truth.
  • Report revenue by carrier, producer, and line, and update contingent commission tracking.

How long should a commission close take?

Manual closes often take weeks. ABP Insurance spent the first three weeks of every month on statement work before automating it. With automated ingestion and reconciliation, the close shifts from data entry to reviewing exceptions.

How AccountAim helps

AccountAim automates the close end to end: Ingest collects and extracts statements, Commission Intelligence reconciles them and queues only the exceptions, and the Commission Engine calculates producer pay with a full audit trail. AccountAim also offers a fully managed monthly commission close for teams that want it handled for them.

Frequently asked questions

When should an agency start its monthly commission close?

Start as soon as the first statements publish and work carriers as they arrive, rather than waiting for every carrier, so the close doesn’t bunch up at month end.

Who should own the commission close?

Typically the controller, accounting lead, or commission manager, with producers and CSRs involved only for exceptions on their accounts.

What should happen to unresolved exceptions at month end?

Carry them forward with an owner, status, and expected resolution date, and report them separately from reconciled revenue.

Can the commission close be outsourced?

Yes. Some providers, including AccountAim, offer a fully managed monthly commission close.

See what your carrier statements are hiding

Bring a few real statements. We’ll show you underpayments, sliding-scale errors, and true-up gaps in a live demo.

Schedule a demo Explore Commission Intelligence

Ready to get started?