Short answer
To find carrier commission underpayments, compare every statement line against the commission you expected for that policy: the right rate for the carrier, line of business, and policy year, applied to the right premium. Then look for policies that should have paid but never appeared. AccountAim reports that brokers typically recover 2–5% of commissions in underpayments.
Why do carriers underpay commissions?
Most underpayments aren’t intentional. They come from rate tables that weren’t updated, endorsements processed at the wrong rate, policies coded to the wrong agency or producer, and adjustments that never posted. Because each carrier pays in its own format and on its own schedule, small errors are easy to miss and hard to prove without policy-level data.
What are the 7 checks that catch underpayments?
- Rate check. Compare the commission rate on each line to the contracted rate for that carrier, line of business, and policy year. New business and renewal rates often differ.
- Premium check. Confirm the premium the carrier used matches the premium in your AMS, including endorsements.
- Missing-policy check. List every policy in your AMS that should have generated commission in the period and confirm it appears on a statement.
- Producer-code check. Make sure business is coded to your agency and the right producer, so commission doesn’t land elsewhere.
- Sliding-scale check. For loss-ratio-based programs, confirm the carrier applied the correct tier for the current loss ratio.
- True-up check. Track adjustments the carrier owes, such as audit premium or year-end adjustments, until they actually arrive.
- Chargeback check. Verify that cancellations and returned premium were charged back at the correct amount and only once.
How much revenue do underpayments cost an agency?
Industry estimates put losses from manual statement processing at 1 to 5% of expected revenue. AccountAim reports that brokers typically recover 2–5% of commissions in underpayments, and in AccountAim’s worked example a $50M book of premium yields about $200K a year in recovered profit. Results depend on your carriers, lines, and how closely you check today.
How do you prove an underpayment to a carrier?
- Cite the policy number, effective date, and transaction type.
- Show the expected rate from the contract or schedule, the rate paid, and the dollar difference.
- Attach the statement line and the governing schedule version.
- Group claims by carrier so one request covers every affected policy.
Why manual checks miss most underpayments
Running seven checks across dozens of carriers every month is more than most teams can do by hand. In practice, agencies only spot an underpayment when someone happens to notice. The fix is to make the checks automatic and let the exceptions come to you.
How AccountAim helps
Commission Intelligence checks every carrier payment against your AMS and your carrier schedules, which are read from carrier PDFs and versioned by contract and policy year. It flags underpayments per policy, with the expected amount, the amount paid, and the difference, so your team has a ready-made claim for each carrier.
Frequently asked questions
What is a commission underpayment?
A commission underpayment is when a carrier pays less commission on a policy than your contract requires, usually because of a wrong rate, a wrong premium base, or a missing transaction.
How far back can an agency recover underpaid commissions?
It depends on each carrier agreement. Check your contracts for dispute windows, and reconcile monthly so issues are raised while records are fresh.
What is the most common cause of underpaid commissions?
Rate errors are among the most common: a rate change, a new-business versus renewal rate, or a line-of-business rate that the carrier applied incorrectly.
Can software detect underpayments automatically?
Yes. Commission software that reconciles statements against your AMS and versioned carrier schedules can flag short payments per policy without manual review of every line.
See what your carrier statements are hiding
Bring a few real statements. We’ll show you underpayments, sliding-scale errors, and true-up gaps in a live demo.
Schedule a demo Explore Commission IntelligenceRelated: What is insurance commission reconciliation? · Sliding-scale commissions explained · What is a commission true-up?